10 Most Controversial Beauty Products
See which skin care, hair, body and makeup goodies TotalBeauty.com readers can't see eye-to-eye on.
Why it's controversial: This is possibly the most debated mascara of all time. Some claim "there is nothing better" and that "I look like I have fake [lashes] on." One reader goes so far as to say, "I cannot see how anyone could not love this mascara." But others clearly don't love it, and say it's "completely overrated" and "don't believe the hype." One reader says, "This mascara is easy to find … and is very affordable, but that is where the pros for this product begin and end ... This mascara never seems to reach every lash, nor does it seem to lengthen or do much of anything."
Which side do you agree with? Weigh in here.
*At time of publication
SEE NEXT PAGE: No. 5: Jergens Natural Glow Daily Moisturizer, $6.99