Editor's Rating & Review
This skinny plastic wand maximizes space with a liner on one end and a smudge brush on the other. The pencil twists up as needed, and creates a smooth line from inner to outer lids. The packaging isn't as sturdy -- it feels cheapie -- and only comes in half the shades of department store equivalent Clinique Quickliner. Flip the smudger, and there's a small sharpener which, unfortunately, you'll use often because the liner is so soft and mush-able.
Maybelline New York Define-A-Line Eye Liner Reviews
only OKthe pros of this product is that the colours are true, prigmented and the liner is very soft so it's easy to apply. However the cons would have to be that is it TOO smudgable, as in, if you try and smudge it it comes off or just vanishes. I have this in navy and while it's ok I will not buy again, I like something with a better formula. — 4 months, 4 weeks agoBon_Bon | 511 reviews
dark, smoothif you want to do a smokey eye, i bet this would be great bc it goes on really dark and smooth and easy, without a hint of tugging. and it has its own smudger and sharpener on the tube. the black i got is very dark, but the way i use liner, for a dramatic cat eye with a wing, it smudges too much. my 'wings' also disapeared towards the 6 hour mark. and i only line the top lid but by the end of the day i had it on top, bottom, inner and out rim. it migrates alot! and it does sting my eyes a bit too. — 4 years, 3 months agocorizotti | 540 reviews
Soft!This eyeliner is very soft and goes on smoothly onto your lids. Great for blending too. The colors are highly pigmented, and the non-black shades are not too bright, so all shades are very wearable. The only thing is that it's not long lasting, so it can smear by the end of the day, especially if you have oily lids. — 3 years, 5 months agoMakeupGuru | 443 reviews
My Reasons for Reporting This