Product Reviews » Makeup » Eyeliner

Eyeliner

	Wet n Wild H2O Proof Blending Eye Pencil Cheap doesn't always mean poor quality, and this pencil proves it. This smudge-proof and waterproof liner is soft enough to glide on smoothly, but not so soft that it slips right off. It also comes with a smudging tool that allows you to create a more smoky finish -- très versatile. This stuff really stays on, an...More See more Wet n Wild products Average rating from 56 members 9
	Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Eyeliner This little pot o' liner is awesome. It goes on easier than a traditional liquid liner -- especially if you use a quality fine-tip brush -- and actually lasts. Other cream or gel liners on the market (like Smashbox Cream Eye Liner) don't have this longevity. A few seconds after you glide it on, it dries and doesn't budge. I...More $19.00See more Bobbi Brown products Average rating from 152 members 9
	Tigi Bedhead Big Fat Fun! For Eyes We're skeptical of any product with an exclamation point in its name, but this little pencil actually is a pretty good time. It glides on extraordinarily easily, gives intense color and somehow doesn't fade throughout the day. It gets a bonus point for the sponge tip at the end that turns crisp lines smudgy and smoldering p...More See more Tigi products Average rating from 15 members 8.5
	Bourjois Effet Metallise This highly metallic pencil liner is ultra creamy and glides on smooth. You can actually use it to line or fill in your entire lid -- it's that soft. The six colors are heavily pigmented, so you won't find yourself needing to apply multiple layers. It should really be a summertime or oily-skin "must-buy," as it st...More $12.00See more Bourjois products Average rating from 13 members 8
	Urban decay Liquid Eye Liner Vintage Bored by your basic black cat eye? Branch out into the eight funky colors of Urban Decay Liquid Eye Liner Vintage to get long-lasting wear delivered by a versatile, quality brush. Pigment density varies from shade to shade, though – purple Crash requires two coats; blue Speed is good with one – so test before buying. Instru...More $14.00See more Urban Decay products Average rating from 17 members 8
	Physicians Formula Eye Definer Felt-Tip Eye Marker Mastering the art of liquid liner is a sweat-breaking, arm-aching chore, but using this "marker" makes the learning curve less grueling. The fine, stiff tip allows you to lay down a straight line without losing control and straying out of line. And it gives you the creative power to make the line thick or thin. On...More $6.95See more Physicians Formula products Average rating from 33 members 8
	Aveda Petal Essence Eye Definer I generally steer clear of pencils for fear that they'll be too hard, too soft or too difficult to sharpen. But this forest management-friendly little guy gives me hope. Though the rich color isn't waterproof, it doesn't smudge or fade unless you work at it. The plastic cap isn't easily lost, as it fits snugly over the firm...More $12.00See more Aveda products Average rating from 16 members 8
	CoverGirl LineExact Liquid Liner This stubby pen combines the best of liquid and pencil liners. The marker tip makes dark pigment glide on without smudging, and it's easy to stash in your purse for touch-ups. (Read between the lines: This liner doesn't last.) The value pricing feels like a bargain until you consider how quickly you'll blow through a tube r...More See more CoverGirl products Average rating from 75 members 8
	Clinique Quickliner for Eyes This slim wand "a liner on one end, a smudge brush on the other" is convenient, long-wearing and it comes in a respectable 14 shades. The twist-up pencil keeps the product moist and fresh, so it delivers on being "silky" and "gliding". But expect less pigment in moist, inner corners of the eye....More $14.50See more Clinique products Average rating from 103 members 7
	MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil The incredible softness of this long-wearing, waterproof pencil makes application so smooth, it looks like eyeshadow. Storing the liner in a cool spot like the fridge will help keep it from getting too creamy. Pigments are rich and varied. How many layers you apply determines how intense the color is, making one pencil not ...More $13.50See more MAC products Average rating from 38 members 7