Editor's Rating & Review
Weightless, yes. Volume? Not so much. If you're looking for a lightweight layer of color and a natural look, this formula manages to separate, coat and condition lashes without clumping or stiffness. But because it's wax-free, you lose the thickening power of competitors, so don't waste your cash if you want high volume -- which you clearly do if you're buying mascara with "volume" in its name. On the upside: We found it safe for contact wearers.
How we review products
Neutrogena Weightless Volume Wax-Free Mascara Reviews
Worst I have triedI thought this would be great being wax-free. Wrong. It applied beautifully and left me with pretty and thick lashes, but between the time I left my house and arrived at work fifteen minutes later, this mascara had melted in the Georgia heat. I had the worst mascara rings around my eyes (which I didn't know until my BOSS saw me). It came off easily, but I was left with no mascara on my lashes. I was really hoping this would be a great summer alternative to regular mascara, but it performed even worse than nonwaterproof mascara. Maybe in a colder climate??? Three stars because prior to meltdown I loved my lashes... — 3 years, 7 months agoradar626 | 322 reviews
Its Okay...This mascara is great for someone who wants very little enhancement in their lashes. This is good for giving a little extra length but nothing too noticeable. It doesn't really give much volume but it does darken your lashes and it doesn't flake. This is a very good natural mascara but I'm just looking for a little something more. — 3 years, 5 months agosephoralove | 14 reviews
Not the bestI love Neutagena products, but this mascara was really disappointing. It was clumpy, smeared and didn't last. When you first put it on, it looks good but it got clumpy within a couple of days. I wouldn't try it again. I'll watch to see if Neutragena develops a better product though, because I trust their quality, and I realize they are new to the makeup game. — 3 years, 5 months agoBellissimo | 6 reviews
My Reasons for Reporting This