Home » Beauty Tips » Makeup » Eye makeup » 9 Eyeliners Not Worth Your Money

9 Eyeliners Not Worth Your Money

Why these eye makeup products made you march to the return counter

1 of 11

According to your reviews, these eyeliners -- some of which had potential to be great -- possessed at least one fatal flaw that was undetectable at the store. Read on to find out which product harbored your biggest pet peeve. (Spot one of your favorites? Write a counter review to boost its rating!)

See Next Page: Stila Kajal Eye Liner, $16.50

By Charli Schuler

Rate this story|Avg member rating: 9

Stila Kajal Eye Liner

Average Member Rating: 5.6

Buy it for $70.00

Physicians Formula Eye Definer Automatic Eye Pencil

Average Member Rating: 4.3

Jane Endless Eye Liquid Eye Liner

Average Member Rating: 3.7

Revlon Bedroom Eyes Powder Liner

Average Member Rating: 3.6

LORAC Front Of The Line Waterproof Eyeliner

Average Member Rating: 2.8

Lola Liquid Eyeliner

Average Member Rating: 2.0

CARGO Eye Pencil

Average Member Rating: 7.5

Buy it for $59.00

L'Oreal Paris Micro Liner Ultra Fine Lining Pencil

Average Member Rating: 4.6

Guerlain 'Divinora' Eye Liner

Average Member Rating: 4.8

When Beauty Products Suck

How to return stuff, and what retailers' return policies make the grade

Eye Makeup Road Test: 11 Best Mascaras

See which eye makeup products gave our editors lust-worthy lashes

Lip Makeup Reviews: The 13 Worst Lip Glosses

Avoid these lip makeup products that readers say left their lips chapped, gooey ... even scabby

I HATE hate hate felt tip "marker" liners!!!

by volta Wednesday, January 25, 2012 at 01:03AM Report as inappropriate

Awh shucks :( i was just about to buy that stila eyeliner too. I would have thought stila and cargo would be the best. Guess not. So glad i read this before buying!

by jasmandermon Thursday, January 5, 2012 at 04:37PM Report as inappropriate

useful

by mgibs96 Wednesday, December 14, 2011 at 12:52PM Report as inappropriate

Its important to know the bad than the good :D Glad I read this.

by Kaps Wednesday, November 16, 2011 at 02:07AM Report as inappropriate

Glad I read this.

by kmb1129 Friday, November 11, 2011 at 10:40PM Report as inappropriate

Thanks! I've never tried any of these, and now won't ;)

by DTalksAll Thursday, October 27, 2011 at 04:22PM Report as inappropriate

thank you...good advice for me :)

by janellelora Monday, September 19, 2011 at 09:08PM Report as inappropriate

Best ever and inexpensive liners are Almay waterproof and Avon Glimmersticks Waterproof. I found the best are water proof as opposed to long lasting, they don't run, smudge or just disapper. You near to wash them off!

by oohlokitzmee Saturday, September 3, 2011 at 09:00PM Report as inappropriate