Editor's Rating & Review
Neutrogena's Extra Gentle Eye Makeup Remover Pads are in fact "extra gentle," which makes sensitive eyes very happy. The non-drying, non-greasy formula leaves lids feeling clean, but removing waterproof mascara can be a little tricky. (I had to use a pad at night and another in the morning.) For non-waterproof mascara, the pads work perfectly. Tip: They are fairly large, so you may be able to get away with cutting them in half, which means you get twice as many pads in one jar.
Neutrogena Extra Gentle Eye Makeup Remover Pads Reviews
I was not impressedThis was a waste of money, in my opinion! It didn't work at all for me. — 2 years agoMissPurple | 591 reviews
It's ok.Using this pads it takes forever to remove makeup from the eyes because they are just barely soaked in makeup remover. I mean, just barely. At the beginning I thought they were dry, but no they aren't. I had to rub and rub several times before getting my makeup off. It is gentle like it says, but not good enough to remove makeup fast. I also like how this smells. Another thing I don't like is that my face looks so shiny after applying this product, hopefully it won't make me break out. — 1 year, 3 months agoyestfl | 207 reviews
WastefulI prefer the liquid makeup remover because I feel like I get more uses out of the bottle and I can use the organic cotton rounds I want. These just seem wasteful to me. — 3 years, 4 months agoTBjunkie | 690 reviews
My Reasons for Reporting This