Bourjois Petit De Guide Style

This duo of eye-color-specific shadow takes the guesswork out of pairing all-over hue and a contouring color (and where to apply each) with a handy picture guide inside. Although shades appear heavy and matte in the package, they go on sheerer and more wearable than you'd think. The gripes: Color creases after three or four hours, the teeny sponge applicator is too stiff to blend properly, the packaging can pop open in your bag and the mini mirror is too small to be useful for anything other than touch-ups.