Editor's Rating & Review
It seems impossible that a "supremely gentle remover" could remove much. But this unscented, non-irritating lotion does it without leaving your eyes slicked with oil. A pea-sized drop is enough for both eyes, so the bottle lasts. The Sephora Professionnel Radical Eye and Lip Makeup Remover is similar, and at only $4, it's tempting to try. But it takes a bigger blob to get rid of makeup and you'll still wake up to raccoon eyes the next morning.
How we review products
Kiehl's Supremely Gentle Eye Make-up Remover Reviews
Eye Makeup RemoverThis is really a good product, but pricey. I have started using L'Oreal, which is just as good. — 1 year, 1 month agoCaroleVonAllten | 1375 reviews
Fantastic EraserThis is an essential makeup remover to your routine, because it goes on thick and creamy and comes off in just one wipe. It does great at removing eye makeup and won't irritate your skin. I love the natural ingredients and that it makes your skin soft and not oily. — 4 years, 6 months agoStef42678 | 482 reviews
Gentle and soothingKiehl makeup remover is excellent. It is gentle and removes all makeup quickly. Value is excellent because it takes so little of the product. — 2 years, 7 months agoPamela937 | 529 reviews
My Reasons for Reporting This