Editor's Rating & Review
This mascara claims to be waterproof, yet somehow it magically washes away with a little soap and water. In reality, this stuff is more water-resistant; it'll hold up if your eyes mist over, but not through a full-on cry fest. And it is a little easier to get off than other waterproof mascaras, but you'll still have to break out the eye makeup remover. As for the wearability? The goopy, thick formula and huge, unwieldy brush do give mega lashes -- along with lots of clumps.
How we review products
CoverGirl Professional Remarkable Washable Waterproof Mascara Reviews
Very familiarCall me crazy but this mascara reminds me of the CG Mega Thick (or something like that) in the pink tube. Exact same brush, exact same formula. I'm on to your tricks, CoverGirl. Anyway. It works fine for day, it doesn't clump, but there is nothing "remarkable" about it. And I don't know if this is just me or what, but by the end of the day it winds up in my eyes and I have to rub most of it out. It comes off with my tears. I find it easy to remove at the end of the day, or I should say "what was left of it" at the end of the day. Not the worst, but I've used better from CG. Not a fan. — 10 months, 1 week agomsbrown822 | 200 reviews
its okayI like this product however, the only thing I found that I did not like about it, is that it is hard to remove. — 5 years agoAmyB58 | 203 reviews
An old go-to productThis is my entire family's favorite. Stays great comes off easy. — 1 year agokyleepickering | 8 reviews
My Reasons for Reporting This