Who Won the Battle Against Dry Hair?

We put eight deep conditioners to the test. See which ones left us high and dry

If your hair feels like straw, it may be time to give it some extra TLC with a deep conditioning treatment. Nelson Chan, celebrity stylist and owner of the Nelson J salon in Beverly Hills, Calif., recommends looking for a protein-based product if your hair is fine or prone to breakage, and a moisture-based product if your hair is thick or coarse. We had women of all hair types test an appropriate deep conditioner for two weeks. Check out their results.

By Sarah Carrillo

Phyto Phytocitrus Vital Radiance Mask , $38 "I was pleasantly surprised with the results this product gave me. After the first use, the mask left my semi-wavy hair smoother and softer. After blow-drying, my hair was less frizzy and seemed sleeker. The texture of the mask was light and fluffy, so I was surprised that it conditioned so deeply. There was no coated, heavy, post-mask feeling at all. The only downside was that I didn't notice further improvement in softness or smoothness with continued use." -- Patti (Medium/Damaged Hair) Frederic Fekkai Protein Rx Reparative Treatment Mask , $28.50 "I used this hair mask for two weeks and loved it. The first use made my hair manageable and shiny and soft, but not greasy. I have fine hair and it didn't make it limp at all -- it actually made it feel fuller! I washed my hair the next day and I didn't even need to condition after shampooing. I used it again later in the week and had the same results. After two full weeks my hair felt much improved. I would recommend this mask to anyone -- especially those with color treated and dry hair." -- Bridget (Fine/Healthy Hair) Joico K-PAK Liquid Reconstructor for Fine Hair , $19.95 "This spray claims to 'reconstruct' the quality of hair. It made mine feel softer, silkier and easier to detangle. My style didn't hold well when I used the product, but it didn't make my hair limp or heavy either. I cut my hair into a chin-length bob since I started using this, so now I get best results when I apply it only on my ends (which can get frizzy), to keep them shiny and smooth." -- Tiffany (Fine/Damaged Hair) Neutrogena Triple Moisture Deep Recovery Hair Mask , $6.99 "The difference in my hair after using this was subtle, but noticeable. The directions only call for once-weekly application, so more extended usage would undoubtedly lead to more dramatic results. After the first use, my hair was softer and had a more glossy finish. My hair is naturally wavy and I use a hot iron daily so I was hoping to find a product that would help repair heat damage. I can't say I noticed improvement in split ends, but the overall difference in texture and ease of styling met my expectations." -- Jennifer (Medium/Healthy Hair) Pantene Pro-V Restoratives Time Renewal Mask , $6.19 "I used this three times over 10 days on my thick, naturally curly hair. After, I noticed that while my hair was extremely soft and shiny, it appeared to have lost some of the volume and natural bounce. I usually wash my hair every other day, but my strands looked greasier than normal on day two. It was also a challenge to open the container, scoop out the product, and try to replace the lid with one hand before water fell into it." -- Lila (Thick/Healthy Hair) Garnier Fructis Sleek & Shine Fortifying Deep Conditioner , $5.49 "After one use, my hair was softer and shinier, but not easier to detangle than with my regular Pureology conditioner. The biggest difference came with styling. After blow-drying and straightening, my hair showed improvement in shine and smoothness -- and results lasted until the next shampoo. If I let my hair air dry, the results only lasted a day or two. The best thing about this mask was that although it felt heavy in the shower, once it was rinsed off, my hair felt light and smooth. On the downside, there was no noticeable improvement with continued use." -- Tatia (Thick/Damaged Hair) L'Oreal Vive Pro Smooth Intense Conditioning Treatment , $4.99 "This mask made my hair feel light and silky even after blow-drying. The mask left no heavy film in my hair and the improved texture seemed to last three days -- until my next washing. I tested this product through several washes and blow-dries (after getting my hair colored), and to my surprise the product was very consistent. After two weeks it continued to leave my hair feeling silky and smooth with fewer frizzes and better manageability. A must-try." -- Jacqueline (Coarse/Healthy Hair) Wella System Professional Power Mask , $38 "I really liked the results this mask gave me. I recently had my highlights redone, making my hair a little dryer than usual. After one use, my hair was softer and shiner and my curls had very little frizz. I would only choose to use this mask once or twice a month though -- more often would make my hair too greasy and weighed down. I would recommend this product to anyone with coarse, over-processed hair or thick, curly hair. I would tell someone with fine or thin hair to skip it, as it may be too heavy." -- Robin (Coarse/Damaged Hair) The Last Word: Try it or Skip it? Try it: Frederic Fekkai Protein Rx Reparative Treatment Mask Joico K-PAK Liquid Reconstructor for Fine Hair Neutrogena Triple Moisture Deep Recovery Hair Mask Phyto Phytocitrus Vital Radiance Mask Garnier Fructis Sleek & Shine Fortifying Deep Conditioner L'Oreal Vive Pro Smooth Intense Conditioning Treatment Wella System Professional Power Mask Skip it: Pantene Pro-V Restoratives Time Renewal Replenishing Mask Fried Hair Rehab Trendy Short Hair Photos 17 Hairstyles That Take Less than 10 Minutes Subject Subject Subject Message Message Message http://www.google.com
leave a comment
older comments

Thank you

by jessicaviolett Friday, May 31, 2013 at 04:00PM Report as inappropriate


by EricaF123 Tuesday, February 26, 2013 at 06:22PM Report as inappropriate

I personally love the pro naturals moroccan argan oil hair mask. Brilliant stuff for hair. I use it once a week like some kind of sacred ritual!

by mary_jacobs Tuesday, December 4, 2012 at 07:07PM Report as inappropriate

I just bought the Neutrogena one, so I'm glad it got a good review! I kind of doubt it will top my all-time favorite deep conditioner though (the Macadamia deep conditioner)!

by Chris213 Sunday, November 4, 2012 at 04:58AM Report as inappropriate

Very informative!!!

by robyne00 Saturday, November 3, 2012 at 08:35PM Report as inappropriate

Hmmm I honestly think the Pro naturals argan oil hair mask is the best for dry hair. It's the only one that actually showed me an improvement!

by laura_wolfhart Thursday, October 25, 2012 at 08:39PM Report as inappropriate

There are some good suggestions to keep in mind. I might try the Loreal Vive conditioner. I haven't heard of most of the other brands so hopefully I'll remember them my next trip to the store.

by flirtygirl214 Monday, August 27, 2012 at 05:32PM Report as inappropriate

I have very fine and thin hair and I color it. I recently went through a bleaching/coloring and so my hair is in that stage where it feels like straw. I have been trying to use home remedies for dry and damaged hair like honey and olive oil. I do keep the Brazilian Deep Conditioning treatment on hand and it works wonders. I've heard that the Moroccan Argan Oil conditioner works wonders too. I have yet to try that particular brand.

by flirtygirl214 Thursday, August 23, 2012 at 05:26PM Report as inappropriate

My hair is thick and curly and the best product I've used to take care of dryness is Pro Naturals Moroccan Argan Oil Conditioner, my hair is hydrated and healthy now :)

by mtaylor722 Tuesday, May 1, 2012 at 03:59PM Report as inappropriate

Aveda Damage Remedy restores all

by TBjunkie Tuesday, May 1, 2012 at 12:43AM Report as inappropriate

- Advertisement -

Home » Beauty Tips » Hair Care » Hair care products » Who Won the Battle Against Dry Hair?
Welcome to TotalBeauty.com!
Ready to unleash your inner beauty junkie? Enter your email and check the boxes below to get free samples, exclusive deals, discounts at Total Beauty Shops, and expert beauty tips delivered straight to your inbox!
Email to a friend