Why it's great: "I have annoying eyelids that smudge all of my eyeshadow and eyeliner within minutes of application," says one reviewer. "But out of all of my eyeliners, this one had minimal smudging, stayed vibrant through my 13-hour day and stayed in place instead of making raccoon eyes." This product, which another user calls her "go-to liner," comes in 13 shades, which readers say are "highly pigmented" with "great staying power."
Agree? Disagree? Write your review here.
*At time of publication
SEE NEXT PAGE: No. 7: NYX Cosmetics Jumbo Lip Pencil, $4.50
Health & beauty