Jaclyn Hill held up a battered Colored Raine Queen of Hearts Palette, and waxed poetic: "They are so pigmented, and so beyond creamy, the mattes, the shimmers -- look how pigmented these mattes are!"
Buy now
It's always nice to find palettes on a budget, right? For fans of some of the higher-end, warm-toned eye shadow palettes on this list, rest assured that NYX has got you covered with their affordable Ultimate Multi-Finish Shadow Palette in Warm Rust. "Oh my gosh, these are so pigmented, and you get so many colors in this palette, said Laura Lee. "And I really love this set-up -- it's a matte, shimmer, and a glitter, so you kind of get a really big bang for your buck. And the color scheme is so pretty!"
Buy now
Photo 9/16
Lorac Mega Pro 3 Palette, $59
Though she pointed out the fact that the palette hadn't been getting the best reviews with other YouTubers, Jackie Aina named the Lorac Mega Pro 3 Palette as one of her go-tos: "I honestly thought this was the best one out of the whole Mega series," she said. "The crease colors were brown-girl-friendly -- they put a matte black, a camel-colored brown and everything in between. This is all I need."
Buy now
The debut of the Anastasia Beverly Hill Subculture Palette was somewhat rife with drama: When it first came out, the backlash was so big that ABH fans that were unhappy with the palette were encouraged to return it for a full refund. That said, for her part, KathleenLights counts herself as a superfan. She admitted that there is some fallout , but in the end, it didn't turn out to be a deal breaker for her. "I really do think it's good," she said, "I love the eye look I created with this."
Buy now
Photo 11/16
Maybelline New York The City Mini Palette x Shayla, $9.99
Shaylamakeup's collaboration with Maybelline New York got a lot of love from the YouTube beauty community: "I've just really, really been loving the combination of colors, the texture, the way that it blends into the skin," said Sona Gasparian of Shayla's palette. She also pointed out, "The shimmers are really gorgeous, and the mattes are really buttery."
Buy now
