If you're looking to up your eyelash game, you might wonder whether
Yves Saint Laurent Mascara Volume Effet Faux Cils Baby Doll, $32, is the key to big, beautiful lashes. This product claims to give you long lashes with plenty of separation and volume. Ahead, find out if YSL Babydoll Mascara lives up to the hype and is the product for you.
YSL Babydoll Mascara Pros and Cons
The Design
Have you ever been jealous of those long, soft eyelashes that framed the eyes of your childhood dolls? If so, YSL Babydoll Mascara claims to be the product that will give you that look thanks to a rubber brush with bristles in two different lengths. The longer ones are spread out to separate and add emphasis to your lashes. The shorter bristles fall between them to catch your finest lashes.
YSL mascara is designed to last for 24 hours of wear. Although you shouldn't leave your makeup on while you sleep, this mascara claims that it will hold up even if you're partying throughout all hours of the night.
The Pros
The YSL Babydoll Mascara is easy to apply. Starting at on the top lashes, swipe the mascara from the roots of your lashes to the tips. Repeat this process on the bottom lashes. Then, add a second coat to the top ones. As one reviewer says, "The effect is quite dramatic with two coats."
The special rubber brush really does help separate lashes to give them definition. Wearers note that the mascara "provides great separation."
Plus, you'll find more than basic black here. Babydoll comes in four highly pigmented colors: Fetish Black, Indiscreet Purple, Audacious Blue and Wheedler Brown.
The Cons
Although the mascara will probably separate your lashes, it may leave clumps behind in the process. Clumpiness is a common complaint among reviewers. One user claims that her lashes became "crispy and clumpy with this mascara." Clumps are most common after applying more than two layers.
Additionally, YSL Babydoll Mascara does a better job of living up to its promise to separate than to its promise to volumize. Without repeated layers, you probably aren't going to majorly boost the appearance of your eyelashes.
Another problem with applying repeated layers is that the mascara has a tendency to flake off during wear. Plus, this formula isn't waterproof and runs pretty easily, especially when your eyes get teary. In other words, the 24-hour claim isn't ideal if you cry, sweat or get caught in the rain.
The Final Analysis
If your main mascara goal is separation, you might agree with reviewers who swear by the power of YSL Babydoll Mascara. But if volume is your highest priority, look elsewhere. Otherwise, you may be frustrated with the clumps and flakes left behind after multiple layers of Babydoll Mascara.