Start by applying primer over the entire eyelid to keep the glitter in place. Then, press and blend Laura Mercier Caviar Stick in Cocoa, $29, into the crease. A neutral shadow from the Sonia Kashuk Eye Palette, $14.29, in Perfectly Neutral, swept over the entire lid, and a dark brown shadow from the set smudged along the lower lash line will recreate Schilling's smoky brown color. Add a dose of shimmer with Stila Magnificent Metals Foil Finish Eye Shadow in Metallic Pixie Dust, $32, over your lid, and finish the look with smudged black liner and mascara.

Oversized lashes paired with frosty silver lids and a rich, berry-stained lip is perfect for New Year's Eve makeup, no matter what you decide to wear. Selena Gomez's scene-stealing chandelier earrings top off a look that brings just the kind of over-the-top glamour NYE calls for. --Hayley Mason

To get Gomez's cranberry lip try Rimmel London Lasting Finish Matte Lipstick in 107, $5.49. For a shimmering smoky eye, start by applying Platinum from the Smashbox #ShapeMatters Palette, $55, all over the lid. Blend Sumatra on the outer corner, and highlight the inner corners with Glow. To get Gomez's crazy-long lashes, apply Eylure Exaggerate False Lashes in 145, $4.99.