When it comes to New Year's Eve makeup, I'll choose a glittery eye over a statement lip every time (I hate dealing with smudged lipstick and touch ups). Taylor Schilling's Emmys look has just the right amount of sparkle to be festive without going OTT, and I love the way her bold brows keep the look defined. --Allie Flinn

Start by applying primer over the entire eyelid to keep the glitter in place. Then, press and blend Laura Mercier Caviar Stick in Cocoa, $29, into the crease. A neutral shadow from the Sonia Kashuk Eye Palette, $14.29, in Perfectly Neutral, swept over the entire lid, and a dark brown shadow from the set smudged along the lower lash line will recreate Schilling's smoky brown color. Add a dose of shimmer with Stila Magnificent Metals Foil Finish Eye Shadow in Metallic Pixie Dust, $32, over your lid, and finish the look with smudged black liner and mascara.

Oversized lashes paired with frosty silver lids and a rich, berry-stained lip is perfect for New Year's Eve makeup, no matter what you decide to wear. Selena Gomez's scene-stealing chandelier earrings top off a look that brings just the kind of over-the-top glamour NYE calls for. --Hayley Mason

To get Gomez's cranberry lip try Rimmel London Lasting Finish Matte Lipstick in 107, $5.49. For a shimmering smoky eye, start by applying Platinum from the Smashbox #ShapeMatters Palette, $55, all over the lid. Blend Sumatra on the outer corner, and highlight the inner corners with Glow. To get Gomez's crazy-long lashes, apply Eylure Exaggerate False Lashes in 145, $4.99.