If you love different mascaras for different reasons, why not combine them to make a super mascara? All you have to do is add a volumizing formula like Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara, $23, to a lengthening formula like CoverGirl Clump Crusher Mascara by LashBlast, $7.99, and you've totally got it made in the shade.
Have you heard about the wonders baby powder can do for your lashes? It's simple as can be, especially since most of us have it lying around the house — and it adds volume like dynamite. All you have to do is dust a little onto your lashes between coats of mascara, and you'll find yourself building up major volume.
If the baby powder mascara tip is a little too DIY for your taste, a product like Make Up For Ever Lash Fibers, $21, can achieve a similar effect. The fibers adhere to your lashes for a volumizing and lengthening boost.
Of course, there are also mascara formulas that come with their own fibers, in case you don't feel like adding an extra step to your makeup routine. Maybelline Illegal Length Fiber Extensions Mascara, $8.99, is a very popular (yet affordable) option.
Along those lines, you might also want to look into tubing mascaras, like the cult fave Blinc Mascara, $26. These form tiny little form tubes around each of your individual lashes, which really helps amp things up a few notches. It also wipes off with water — no scrubbing or makeup remover required.