Why it's great: This mascara may be old-school, but "it's the only mascara that makes me look like I have long, beautiful lashes," says Ulta.com reviewer. Another Ulta.com reviewer adds, "It gives great volume and length without looking glomped on or spidery, even when layered." The brush "has the perfect amount of mascara on it, so it doesn't clump or need to be wiped off a little before you apply," writes another Ulta.com reviewer.
Buy now
*At the time of publication
