GET FREE SAMPLES

sign up for our newsletter to get free sample alerts
Photo 1/8
Bad news for all of us pale folks: There really is no such thing as a "safe" tan. We already knew that tanning beds and laying out in the sun were killing us slowly, but now it seems we need to add spray tans and self-tanners to the list.

"I used to recommend spray tans and tell my patients there's no risk, but now I have some reservations," says Darrell Rigel, MD, a professor of dermatology at New York University. The reason he's concerned: the release of several studies showing that the active ingredient in spray tans, DHA, may damage DNA and cause cancer.

Naturally, as fellow advocates of spray tans (and as beauty editors who have spent our fair share of time in a spray tan booth), we were also worried. But since we live in a world where a trip through airport security or a call on our cell phones can also be considered risky, we weren't quite ready to pull the plug on our Mystic Tan sessions. We wanted to do some digging first and find out just how bad spray tans are for you, and if you really do need to give them up for good.

Click here for the full story on spray tan dangers.

What we found was pretty shocking (and yes, a little scary). Keep reading to see the latest research and what the skin care experts have to say about spray tans, and decide for yourself if it's worth the risk to get a glow.

Photo 2/8
What we know about spray tans for sure
While there haven't been extensive studies done on DHA and human cells, there have been several studies done on bacteria, animal, and other cells. Here's a breakdown of what they found:

• DHA can penetrate the skin and be absorbed into living skin cells. It was previously believed that it didn't get past the dead skin cells on top of your skin, says Rigel.
• Studies have found that DHA can alter the genes of cells. This hasn't been proven to happen with human cells yet, but Rigel says typically if these results are found with bacteria or animal cells, human cell testing is next.
• In addition to cancer risk, Lynn Goldman, MD, MPH, dean of the School of Public Health and Health Services at George Washington University, says there may also be risks for birth defects if a pregnant woman gets spray tans. However, this is only based on the initial studies done, since there have not been any studies on spray tanning and pregnant women.

Photo 3/8
The real deal with DHA
Many spray tanning salons reassure customers by telling them that DHA is a food grade ingredient and safe to eat. And that's technically true -- but not when it comes to the DHA in spray tans.

There are actually two chemicals that are abbreviated DHA: One is Docosahexaenoic acid, an essential fatty acid that's often added to infant formula, but never to self-tanner. The other is Dihydroxyacetone, the active ingredient in spray tans, which is a colorless sugar that literally stains your dead skin cells brown, giving you your tan. "These two DHAs are not the same thing," says Rigel. "When someone says you can eat the DHA solution, they're talking about the food-grade DHA."

When ABC news did their initial report, they found Norvell Skin Solutions, one of the largest manufacturers of spray tan products, was telling its customers that they used food-grade DHA in their products. Norvell has since promised to correct its product descriptions.

Photo 4/8
Are lotions safer than sprays?
The biggest concern with spray tans is that you could easily inhale the solution, which means DHA is getting into your lungs and then into your bloodstream. Rey Panettieri, MD, a toxicologist and lung specialist at the University of Pennsylvania's Perelman School of Medicine, says if DHA gets into your bloodstream there is a chance "these compounds in some cells could actually promote the development of cancers or malignancies, and if that's the case then we need to be wary of them."

Obviously, it's hard to inhale a lotion, so Rigel says this form of self-tanner is a somewhat safer bet. "I would say lotions are safer than spray tanning guns because you're not going to breathe in the lotion," he says. "But there's still some risk since your skin can absorb the DHA in lotions," he says.

Rigel and other dermatologists familiar with spray tanning studies are still hesitant to recommend self-tanner lotions. That's because a 1999 study by the FDA found that 11 percent of DHA applied to the skin is going beyond the dead skin cells sitting on top of your skin and getting absorbed into living skin cells in the epidermis and dermis. Further studies are necessary to see if the DHA is actually harming these skin cells, but the fact that it's there at all worries many experts.

"The concern here is we never thought DHA was getting absorbed," Rigel said in his ABC interview. "We thought it's binding to the surface of the skin and that's where the stain is." But this study changes that belief, he says.

Photo 5/8
Minimize your risk
If you don't want to stop spray tanning, there are ways to at least minimize the amount of DHA that gets in your system. Rigel recommends covering your eyes with goggles and using nose plugs. But he warns there may still be some absorption, since the particles can stay in the air and goggles and nose plugs don't block everything.

If you decide to get a spray tan, you might want to bring your own eye covers and nose plug, though: ABC News found that nine out of 12 salons they visited didn't have these in stock.

Bad news for all of us pale folks: There really is no such thing as a "safe" tan. We already knew that tanning beds and laying out in the sun were killing us slowly, but now it seems we need to add spray tans and self-tanners to the list.

"I used to recommend spray tans and tell my patients there's no risk, but now I have some reservations," says Darrell Rigel, MD, a professor of dermatology at New York University. The reason he's concerned: the release of several studies showing that the active ingredient in spray tans, DHA, may damage DNA and cause cancer.

Naturally, as fellow advocates of spray tans (and as beauty editors who have spent our fair share of time in a spray tan booth), we were also worried. But since we live in a world where a trip through airport security or a call on our cell phones can also be considered risky, we weren't quite ready to pull the plug on our Mystic Tan sessions. We wanted to do some digging first and find out just how bad spray tans are for you, and if you really do need to give them up for good.

Click here for the full story on spray tan dangers.

What we found was pretty shocking (and yes, a little scary). Keep reading to see the latest research and what the skin care experts have to say about spray tans, and decide for yourself if it's worth the risk to get a glow.
BY SARAH CARRILLO | SHARES
VIEW COMMENTS
Full Site | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy
TotalBeauty is a property of Evolve Media Holdings, LLC. © 2024 All Rights Reserved. | Affiliate Disclosure: Evolve Media Holdings, LLC, and its owned and operated subsidiaries may receive a small commission from the proceeds of any product(s) sold through affiliate and direct partner links.