Makeup

Our editors checked out the top 10 percent of makeup products, as rated by TotalBeauty.com readers. From that pool we chose the Total Beauty Award winners below. A second type of award for each category -- Readers' Choice -- was awarded based on our readers' votes. And now, on to the winners ...

Best Blush
  • Editors' Pick

    Nars Blush

    An amazing array of shades to choose from including the cult-fave "Orgasm" -- this blush blends like a dream.

  • Readers' Choice

    Nars Blush

    "The price is intimidating, but the results are drawing me into sweet temptation." -- starluxe

Best Bronzer
Best Brow Enhancer
  • Editors' Pick

    Anastasia Brow Powder Duo

    Perfect, light coverage to enhance brows without looking like a cartoon villain. Good color choices.

  • Readers' Choice

    Smashbox Brow Tech

    "You can mix the colors to darken or lighten the color; they blend seamlessly with your own brows and look perfectly natural." -- mdallas22

Best Concealer
Best Eyeliner
  • Editors' Pick

    MAC Eye Pencil

    These are soft enough to line your inner rims with, but won't melt off your eyes midday.

  • Readers' Choice

    Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

    "This pencil is a dream -- soft, easy to apply, densely colored. Once the color sets, it lasts all day." -- pkittie

Best Eyeshadow
  • Editors' Pick

    MAC Eye Shadow

    With a foolproof formula and hundreds of shades to choose from, it's hard to stray from this classic shadow.

  • Readers' Choice

    MAC Eye Shadow

    "Every shade, used wet or dry, comes out perfect every time." -- missannnie

Best Foundation
Best Highlighter / Multi-Tasker
  • Editors' Pick

    Benefit Benetint

    For a quick, natural makeup look, this is all you need. Slick it on lips (with some gloss) and cheeks for a post-workout, rosy glow.

  • Readers' Choice

    Bare Escentuals bareMinerals All-Over Face Color

    "Even if I don't wear my foundation, I will dust a little over my face for a sun kissed look." -- mikkioz

Best Lip Balm
  • Editors' Pick

    Korres Natural Products Lip Butter

    This "butter" is so much more than a basic ho-hum balm. Not only does it make lips pillowy soft, it also adds a perfect hint of color.

  • Readers' Choice

    Burt's Bees Beeswax Lip Balm

    "Can't live without it. The consistency is perfect, with just enough beeswax to feel creamy and keep it on your lips." -- medic586

Best Lip Gloss
Best Lipstick
  • Editors' Pick

    Nars Velvet Matte Lip Pencil

    Fabulous, high-pigment color that lasts a crazy long time, plus a matte finish that doesn't look dry.

  • Readers' Choice

    MAC Lipstick

    "MAC lipsticks are the best! They go on so smoothly and stay put. There are so many colors to choose from." -- brooke3333

Best Mascara
  • Editors' Pick

    Lancome Definicils Mascara

    One coat gives you clump-free lashes that are so long, they practically touch your eyebrows. Plus, it doesn't flake or smudge.

  • Readers' Choice

    CoverGirl LashBlast Volume Blasting Mascara

    "So what mascara works? LashBlast does! After I've curled my lashes, the mascara definitely adds a lot of thickness and fullness." -- cleegiants

Best Nail Polish / Treatment
  • Editors' Pick

    Essie Nail Polish

    The formula goes on like a dream and lasts. Classic shades like Mademoiselle are flawless and trendy seasonal hues send us speeding to the beauty supply.

  • Readers' Choice

    OPI Classic Shades Nail Lacquer

    "Whether you are experimenting with new looks or trying to make a fashion statement, all of these colors are rich, vibrant and high quality." -- ModernDayWriter

Best Powder
Best Primer / Shine Control
Best Tool