This eyeliner is nothing but a chalk pencil! It's hard, doesn't blend, and crumbles a few weeks after use. I love the pearly sheen, however, and really wish they would consider reformulating this into something smoother and better for our eyes!
by theycallmerainbow | 106 reviews
8.0
"ACTUALLY NOT THAT BAD!"
I really don't understand why people give it these awful reviews. It's kind of like a white eyeliner pencil. In all truth, it's actually not that bad! I don't use it as an actual eyeliner, however. The ways I use this pencil are odd, like penciling in a little white dash in the inner corner...
I love elf, but this product was a flop. Its formula is terrible, and it doesn't make your eyes look wider. Get a white liner from another product line (suggested: Urban Decay).
by Monnrella | 68 reviews
7.0
GOOD FOR OTHER THINGS
I don't think this is a good option for my water line. Like others have said, the color is too sheer and sparkly. It just doesn't look natural enough on the waterline to give you that wide eyed look. It is, however, a pretty decent cheek and browbone highlighter. Just apply it and blend and it...
by yinyxlum | 23 reviews
1.0
NO. JUST NO.
Needs to be creamier so that it would actually stay on our eyes. You can rub and rub but it's so solid and compact that none with come off. I'm debating taking the actual colored part out, mashing it, putting it in a little container and adding a tiny bit of glycerin. That would probably make it...
by mla | 36 reviews
GET FREE SAMPLES
sign up for our newsletter to get free sample alerts