Clumpy, left my lashes looking gross and rubbed off on my skin too fast. Not exactly an ideal mascara.
by statickyogo | 160 reviews
6.0
IT'S OKAY
It's not terribly horrible but it's also not the greatest...it definitely IS waterproof. Probably one of the most waterproof cosmetics I have ever tried. It does not want to come off which can be annoying sometimes. I usually use this for onstage purposes (I'm in theatre) and it's perfect for...
I've always been fairly impressed with NYC products. This mascara definitely holds up to the water, tears, etc. The only downside was it left my lashes kind of gloppy.
by Andiex | 7 reviews
8.0
GOOD PRODUCT FOR THE PRICE
This is a good product for the price. This is the only waterproof mascara I have used that didn't irritate my eyes.
by chellebelly | 4 reviews
7.0
WATERPROOF!
I've gone through many waterproof mascara's and NYC Waterproof Mascara is the only one that can was able to stay on even after a storm of crying. The only thing I don't like about this mascara is that it gets clumpy after a few use.
by Emogene | 5 reviews
GET FREE SAMPLES
sign up for our newsletter to get free sample alerts