It actually is really dark when you put it on which of course what everyone wants for an eyeliner I don't really have anything to say bad about it!
by haileyb | 33 reviews
9.0
GOING ON 2 YEARS
I love this product. It's gentle on my eyes and lasts all day without a lot of smudging or disappearing. It can get a little dry but i sharpen it and heat it with my blow dryer just a little
I use this pencil everyday! I dip the pencil in a gel eyeliner and the NYC liner plus the gel eyeliner mixed together work great! The NYC liner alone is very pigmented. I have the liner in black and it is a true black not a dark gray. It doesn't stay on as long as I like so that is why I would...
by emily_rocchio | 3 reviews
9.0
BEAT MY EXPECTATION
I bought this on sale in a dusky purple that I wasn't really expecting to show up much because I had such a bad experience with the automatic pencil, but then I put it on and WOW. The color was so bright (or as bright as this shade can be) and vibrant, and it definitely showed. It's also very...
by Kokome | 25 reviews
3.0
NOT BLACK
After I read the reviews I was really looking forward into trying this on my waterline but this is not black and it looks gray compared to my usual smearing kohl eyeliner. Disappointed. Not smooth either.
by Hungrystorm | 5 reviews
GET FREE SAMPLES
sign up for our newsletter to get free sample alerts