This is by far the best drugstore mascara I've tried, and I have tried A LOT of them. I'm obsessed with mascara, it's kind of ridiculous. This gave the best lush, long, but natural looking lashes. I haven't been able to find it in stores for at least 2 years. The new mascara in the orange tube...
by Sc2501 | 55 reviews
4.0
TOO NATURAL LOOKING
This mascara was as close to not wearing mascara at all as - well - not wearing mascara at all. It was more like combing my lashes and adding a thin layer of mascara. It was almost not worth using at all. It did not lengthen or thicken the lashes.
This, along with L'Oreal's Double Extend mascara, are awesome. I have yet to try the waterproof version of the FeatherLash, but this one works great! It fans out my lashes nicely, doesn't clump, and adds just the right touch if you're trying to go for a more finished, natural look.
by BellaFaccia | 33 reviews
9.0
FOR NATURAL LOOKING LASHES
I use the voluminous mascara for when I want more coverage and this for when I want to look more natural. This goes on really smooth and does a good job at lengthening my lashes. It stays on too...no clumps fall off onto my face. I recommend this.
by sumake | 9 reviews
8.0
ALL TIME FAVORITE
This has been my all time favorite mascara. It does not clump or flake and stays on all day. Removal is easy with soap and water.
by anna487 | 4 reviews
GET FREE SAMPLES
sign up for our newsletter to get free sample alerts