Slides off all day leaving you with smudges and you'll use a ton of eye liner fixing the mess all day
by laura_nicole_mcguinness | 38 reviews
10.0
SOFT PENCIL LINERS ARE SUPPOSED TO SMUDGE!
Unless you use this pencil with an eyeshadow primer or long-lasting eyeshadow, it does what it's supposed to: smudge (AKA softening the line). If you want a budge-proof daily eyeliner, try Sephora brand liquid eyeliner.
I usually love Physicians Formula products but not this one. I have to apply it a few times to get intense color. The eyeliner doesn't last long and smears after a while. I wouldn't buy this product again.
by ToTheMoon | 130 reviews
2.0
DISAPPOINTED
Smudges horribly, very thick. Does not come out easily
by LoveMyBoysBZ | 51 reviews
3.0
SMUDGE
smudges, feels thick.
by Melies | 62 reviews
GET FREE SAMPLES
sign up for our newsletter to get free sample alerts