My newest love! It's tough to find a tinted balm that actually balms and tints and this one does...while also featuring a seriously cute heart-shaped bullet. And in addition to being heart-shaped, it's also on the thinner side for a lippie, which together with the click-pen applicator, makes it very easy to wield.
Last but not least, you're going to want to top things off with a little mascara that'll add polish without overwhelming the rest of your low-key look. This is the mascara to do it. Even after multiple coats, your lashes will still look natural (and sans clumps too). Plus, it's forgiving enough that you can swipe it on in a hurry without worrying too much about uneven lashes.