Have you tried Lime Crime's matte liquid lippies before? They're definitely unicorn-worthy with their long-wearing (and kiss-proof!) formula and dramatic matte finish. Cashmere is an especially popular shade from the line: it's a mauve-y beige that has gorgeous lavender undertones that make it pretty unique (though not completely unique, of course). Colourpop Ultra Matte Lip in Trap is an almost perfect shade dupe with the same matte effect — for less than $7.
Buy Lime Crime
Buy ColourPop Cosmetics