Gone are the days when natural eyeliners lasted about two seconds. Over the last few years, there's been a lot of innovation in the clean eyeliner category. So now you can find plenty of formulas that are safe, nontoxic and actually stay put. Whether you prefer pencil, gel or liquid, there's a clean eyeliner for everyone.
We rounded up our favorite clean eyeliners to help you create both subtle and dramatic makeup looks. Don't forget to finish things off with a clean mascara.
Image via Imaxtree
PYT Beauty Wingman Liquid Liner, $15.99
Available in black and navy, this clean liquid eyeliner is vegan, hypoallergenic and water-resistant. The flexible felt tip can be used to create the perfect winged liner look that lasts all day long. Plus, the packaging is made from 40 percent recycled plastic.
This clean eyeliner has a waterproof gel formula for eye makeup that doesn't budge. Made from a natural wax blend, this vegan liner glides on smoothly without tugging. Boasting black, brown and bronze shades, it's perfect for everyday wear.
You can now perfect Lauren Conrad's iconic cat eye with the former reality TV star turned fashion and beauty mogul's clean liquid eyeliner. The formula is contact lens safe so you don't have to worry about it irritating your eyes and it delivers intense color. Another bonus? The packaging is made with 100 percent recyclable materials.
For liquid eyeliner that doesn't flake, try this clean formula. It contains passionflower extract to ensure the rich, black eyeliner won't dry out as well as fruit-derived pectin for even application.