"I used the peach gloss from the same NP Set Gorgeous-To-Go Palette, $27, that Rosie used for a little color. I didn't want to go too dark since I already had a lot going on with my eyes. I think this is perfect for the office. The brown shades make it way more wearable for day than the usual black smoky eye."

Want to see how Kristin and Rosie tackle other palette challenges? Click here!