"I stole a page out of Kristin's book and also used NP Set Lip Balm with Benefits, $10, but in the Baja shade to complement my dress.

"I think I look pretty date ready, right? The berry lip and bronzy smoky eye is probably a little dressier than I'd usually go for on a Saturday, but it's still pretty and doesn't give off a trying-too-hard vibe."

Want to see how Kristin and Rosie tackle other palette challenges? Click here!