Calories per Pint: ~360
This high-fiber ice cream isn't quite as sweet as the others but with 26 flavors to choose from, you're sure to find the smooth, creamy treat you're craving — or at least a healthier version of it!
Buy now
Calories per Individual Fluid Oz. Cup: 160
Despite being higher in calories for the size than the rest of the brands we tried, you get a whole lot of protein in every cup. What's more, each of the four flavors — chocolate, vanilla, ginger and espresso ‐ tastes absolutely delicious.
Buy now
Calories per Pint: 260 - 330
This newly launched healthy ice cream alternative is from your childhood supermarket favorite, Breyers. Of all the protein ice creams that we've tried, Breyers Delights is the closest to real ice cream by far. The creamy texture and chocolatey bits make for a heavenly spoonful every time. In total, there are seven flavors to choose from, including cookies and cream, vanilla cupcake and mint chip.
Buy now
Calories per Pint: ~420
Talk about protein-packed! This high-protein blend combines clean ingredients to create a nutritious dessert that can serve as your day-end delight. We were pleasantly surprised to find that the nine flavors, while certainly healthy, don't taste like chalky versions of coconut, mocha or mint chip ice cream.
Buy now
Calories per Pint: 150
If you're more of a shaved ice kind of gal, you'll love this ultra-lightweight ice cream. Made with real milk, cream and cane sugar, the creators somehow manage to whisk all the ingredients so finely that it almost tastes like watered-down ice cream. While that may not cut it when you're craving actual ice cream, the airy taste is just enough to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Buy now
