Summer beauty may be all about going au natural and maintaining a sun-kissed glow, but that doesn't mean the end of dark, sultry eyes. Even if you've already pulled out your poolside beauty essentials, we thought we'd showcase this fierce eye makeup look as an alternative to your natural, beachy makeup routine. Both Karlie Kloss and Kate Upton pulled off a smize-worthy, smoldering eye in a model-to-model faceoff. Paired with a nude, lightly glossed lip, the effect is dramatic and chic. But we want to know from you: Which smoky eye do you love and why?

More on TotalBeauty.com
•Get Beach-Sexy Hair in a Bottle
•Our Nasty Beauty Habits Revealed
•24 Best Shampoos