The color, consistency, texture, felt tip pen applicator, and easy to carry around packaging are great, this bad boy dries up so fast. I used it every day for probably 2 weeks, never left the top un-clicked, and it dried up on me. There are a lot of liquid liners out there, and as far as comparison goes, this didn't completely blow me away. It was fine, but having to buy a new one every 3 or so weeks seems totally preposterous. Oh well.

I personally prefer a felt tip for liquid eyeliner, it seems to be easier to manage. This particular eyeliner is terrible, for $20, you would think it would last. This eyeliner does not last, it does not have the ball bearings to shake up the formula because it is all in one felt strip thus it does not last more then say, a month. $20, really? The color is not lasting, not waterproof, and the consistency is wax like. Coming from a felt tip, you can imagine the quality. PLEASE DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY!!!!

I really liked this eyeliner, it glided on really nicely, and it made perfect lines..however, I'd have to agree with most of the other reviews, the tip dried out way fast... I took it back to see if I could exchange it (I thought maybe I had just gotten a defective tube) and the 2nd tube did the exact same thing. So, once again, I took it back and the sales associate suggested that you shake it...didn't work. Needless to say, I returned it and I now use Urban Decay 24/7...LOVE IT!

it doesnt even come out of the tube! i wasted $20 there!!! >:[ dont even think of buying it because its crap! the brand is amazing, just not there liquid liner

This product did dry out extremely fast. It was done before I got any good wear out of it. Tried the shaking method but all it did was make me want a pencil rather than liquid