Runny, stings the eyes. I would never use this awful product again.

No way, this stuff is messy, ugly and pretty much worthless. First of all it's so hard to apply, it goes all over the eye and takes forever to dry. Not to mention it smears and sure doesn't last more then an hour if ANYTHING touches your eye. I took a sweater off three hours after applying this and guess where the liner ended up? No not just all over my eyes, but as a nice long streak on my sweater. Save money on your trash bill and avoid this.

this definatley doesn't last 16 hours

I like a lot of Jane products so when I saw this at the store, I said to myself "why not give it a try"? Well, I can't say I'm too pleased with it. While the packaging was sleek and application was easy enough, the product did not live up to it's advertised claim of 16 hrs. I don't have oily eyelids but at 2 hrs after, the product started flaking off of my eyes. Not a pretty look at all! By the 4th hr, it was almost all gone, except for a few patches here and there. I can't complain too much though. For the price, I didn't expect it to last 8 hrs, much less 16.

Tough to fix mistakes, but again I am not a makeup artist.