The line is too heavy and it smudges too easily.

Interesting colors but not the nice Taupe color they used to have (a little too dark)..and the line is too heavy, my eyes, are big, but if anything this one made them look smaller.

This is only nice if you want to do a smokey eye and you need something that smudges easily. Other than that, I'd stay away. It's too messy for me. It's more of a gray tone, not black enough.

Slides off all day leaving you with smudges and you'll use a ton of eye liner fixing the mess all day

Unless you use this pencil with an eyeshadow primer or long-lasting eyeshadow, it does what it's supposed to: smudge (AKA softening the line). If you want a budge-proof daily eyeliner, try Sephora brand liquid eyeliner.