Jordana Cosmetics INCOLOR Fabuliner Liquid Eyeliner by Jordana Cosmetics, Eyeliner Review

Reviews / Jordana Cosmetics INCOLOR Fabuliner Liquid Eyeliner

8

Love It, But New Formula Please!

First off, I very much love this eyeliner. It's easily replaced many of my more expensive eyeliners such as my Stila Stay All Day and Kat Von D Tattoo liners. The pen has a wonderfully precise felt tip that hasn't gone dull or create this funny bend at the point like some other liners I've tried. The black formula is incredibly dark and dries in no time at all too! The packaging is nice and slim,...read more easy to hold, and the cap clicks into place so your eyeliner doesn't dry out after a couple of weeks! Like all other eyeliner pens, it's best stored with the cap down so the felt tip can always be saturated with the formula and doesn't end up creating those watered-down streaks on the next application. Don't let the price tag fool you! I was so impressed by the performance I recommend it to everyone I know, despite what I have to say about it next: Despite all the good things I have to say about this eyeliner, I do have a problem of it flaking, smearing, and disappearing on me by the end of the day. I love the easy application, the packaging, everything, but there are some days when this eyeliner wants to flake, some days when it wants to smear all over my undereye, and some days it just disappears by evening! Basically, the formula needs a reworking or perhaps just a new waterproof version. I do have oily eyes, which is why I'd still recommend that others try this liner for themselves, but I've never experienced all three types of eyeliner problems with one product before! Therefore, primer is a necessity for me if I am to wear this liner. But hey! At about $2.00 a liner that has so many other great perks, the price just can't be beat!

theycallmerainbow | 106 reviews

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 4 of 4 people said helpful
10

Amazing

This eyeliner is simply amazing, I do not know how to justify this product with words, but I will try my best! First off I was in CVS the other day and saw that there was a 30% off Jordana cosmetics, I had always been curious about their products since they were so cheap, I thought they could be the new Wet and Wild sort of thing, shabby packaging but great quality products inside, make up gems. B...read moreut anyhow I had wanted to try out the liquid eyeliner because I am a huge fan of asian type of liquid pen liners, but I noticed they were kind of hard to find in the US. I saw some from Stilla and the Sephora brand, but I didn't feel like spending more than $10 on an eyeliner that would dry out in give or take 2 months time so when I saw this product at CVS I was a bit excited, I picked up a black and some other color that I gifted away, but anyhow the black was very black. I liked how the formula was not extremely thin so I did not have to go over my liner a bunch of times! That doesn't mean I didn't, I felt like one stroke was not enough so I did 2 strokes of liner and it was very black. It managed to stay on my eye all day, it did not smudge off which was amazing!!! I feel like it had amazing staying power which was a super plus!!! This product was really cheap, I think I paid about $1.50 for it!!! It lasted me about 2 months or so as well which was really good. I do not know if this brand is really popular since I've only seen it at CVS and there is a really small section devoted to it, but yes I really do hope every gets exposed to this brand it deserves the publicity!!! It's extremely affordable, does a great job, the color payoff is good, and the lasting power is super! What more can one want in a liquid liner right?

Misselizabeth | 38 reviews

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 9 of 12 people said helpful
9

I love it but..

First of all I LOVE Jordana products! I wish they had more selection in my store, but instead they're put off to the side in a very small section. Anyway, I have this eyeliner in 2 colors, the brown and black. I love them both, but the only problem is, the color inside comes out onto the area outside the felt tip. I've gotten smudges before. The package tells me to store it horizontally, which I d...read moreo but I'm not sure why it leaks out like that.. not a lot but in little dots of ink. Also this might smudge for me but it might be the mascara too.. I try to use Jordana mascara too. I love how their products are almost half the price of the other drugstore brands, yet almost just as good if not better than them as well! :D

Angelamay14 | 83 reviews

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 0 of 1 people said helpful
16 Best Eyeliners under $10
Exclusively from the editors at Total Beauty

Get the Buying Guide to see these top-rated products!
Get it now »
7

A Great Drugstore Option

This is a great/affordable eyeliner. I have a hard time finding it, so whenever I can find it in the drugstore, I grab a few (they're only about $3 here in NYC). They only come in two colors, brown and black. The packaging is really nice and sturdy. There is a lot of product in each tube and unlike a lot of other felt tip pen eyeliners, I find that this one does not easily dry out (YES!). I would ...read morenot say its the BEST drugstore eyeliner out there. But considering the price point, its really great. I have oily eyelids and I find that the eyeliner that I apply closest to my inner corner ALWAYS smudges with this pen. It starts smudging as soon as 15 mins before I apply it. I have started using a more expensive liner in the inner corner and this for the rest of the line. And so far its working nicely!

Billie77 | 85 reviews

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 0 of 0 people said helpful
4

decent

I liked the color of this eyeliner. Although it wasn't very longlasting, it faded quckly. Also the tip was thick making it difficult to get a natural, thin line. It always looked messy and uneven. It was decent for the price but I wouldn't repurchase it.

mikenza | 77 reviews

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 1 of 1 people said helpful
2

DULL !

This product is very dull and i have to go over the lines several times for it to show. I was very disappointed with this product because this product got so many good ratings. It honestly was like a sharpie that was drying out that I used on my eye lids. The only thing good is it doesn't smudge or run and it creates a crisp line

ashleigh_notz | 5 reviews

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 2 of 2 people said helpful
4

What's with the high ratings?

Great price, but it's a cheap eyeliner! Watery, runny, dries out quick, and in spite of that still average. Bought both black and brown, and definitely prefer the brown. I got it because of the high ratings and was drastically let down.

karima_boukary | 8 reviews

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 2 of 2 people said helpful
10

Holy grail eyeliner!

This is such an amazing eyeliner! This is my holy grail liquid eyeliner. This is perfect for anyone, beginners and experts. When I first started using liquid eyeliner I could not get it close to my lash line to save my life. But then, I bought this eyeliner and it was so easy to apply. I've gotten much better at apply eyeliner but this is still a go to for me. It's only $1.99 at Wallgreens. If I h...read moread one complaint it would be that this isn't sold at many places. I've only seen it at Wallgreens and there aren't many around me. I wish it was sold at CVS or Rite Aid.

kelsey_tunnell | 40 reviews

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 0 of 2 people said helpful
6

Not a perfect 10

Although it is easy to apply, the eyeliner isn't nearly pigmented enough. I bought black and it looks grey and watery when applied. I would definitely not give it a perfect 10.

alletta_simons | 1 reviews

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 1 of 1 people said helpful
16 Best Eyeliners under $10
Exclusively from the editors at Total Beauty

Get the Buying Guide to see these top-rated products!
Get it now »
10

A Standout Product

This liquid liner is my standard go to product for any look I create. I've used this for months and have discontinued using all others in my collection. This product allows you to apply liner with ease, flexible applicator and great color. The ONLY not so great side to this liner is that it's not waterproof. However, for normal everyday where, it really won't matter if you're only using this product for your upper lash line. Highly recommend.....great investment!!

angela_kennedy | 3 reviews

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 6 of 6 people said helpful