Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner Reviews

Back to Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner»
Sort by:
  • 7

    GREAT! Except for Waterline :/

    Bottom Line: This is a really,really good product for just a regular eyeliner to use on your top lid or below the water line, but it does NOT stay on the water line for more than 2 hours. Full Review: This product is mas o menos (so so). I use eyeliner every single time that I apply makeup, and I only put it on my water line, except for those certain times when I feel like putting it on the top moreid. This product is not good to use on your water line. At all. Well, thats a lie. I mean it isn't THAT bad... It only lasts for like, 2 or 3 hours at the most though, which really is a huge problem for me, because I'm at school for 6 hours, and my eyeliner is gone by my 3rd class! That is a huge problem for me. All I want, is a good water line eyeliner. In fact, if any one knows one, can they please contact me? Haha sorry, I went a little off topic. So continuing with the review, I really just wish that it lasted longer. For the first hour or two, its perfect! It actually comes out very black (like some claim to do, but usually don't) and that is one thing I really like about this. For those who don't put it on the water line, I really do recommend this product. It works so well when you aren't trying to make it stay on the water line! Ugh, I just wish it did. I still have yet to find something that does stay, and I just ordered another stila eyeliner, which I am hoping works better. But even though it doesn't stay for as long as I might like for it too, I still use it every day, because I am not just getting rid of something I spent twenty dollars on. I normally wait for deals when it comes to makeup,but I really thought this would work, because a couple of my friends had suggested it to me. I really like the design of the product too! It's a little black stick with a twisty tip! The only problem I have with it, is that if you break the tip, you can't sharpen it, and also my twisty part is super duper loose now :( I thought that since this was such a respectable brand their containers would be good quality too but I guess not.. maybe mine is just defective. Haha. Well all in all, this product is a very,very good one, if you are not planning on using it for your water line. If you are, steer clear, and try something else. I don't have any recommendations, because I have yet to find one for myself, but this works great on any other place you may want to use eyeliner. Actually, it works good on your upper water line, just not the lower one! Sorry, just realized that. But yes, this is not for your lower water line if you are looking for something that will stay for a very long time! Hope I helped! — 2 years, 4 months ago
    jrp4621 | 29 reviews

    This review is:  Helpful  |  Not helpful  |  Inappropriate  |  0 of 0 people said helpful

  • 8


    I am in love with the color of this liner. It's is a beautiful shimmery bronze color and I just adore it. It is extremely long wearing and settle quickly, which is a huge plus. I can make a swatch on my hand, put the cap back on, place it back in my makeup drawer and then rub my hand across it and it's already dry. I left it on my hand all day to see how it would do and it didn't disappear until morebout 7 hours later. The only downside is that it doesn't come with a sharpener and the tip can become a bit dull so lining eyes requires a bit for finesse. — 2 years, 4 months ago
    RamblingMaam | 82 reviews

    This review is:  Helpful  |  Not helpful  |  Inappropriate  |  2 of 2 people said helpful

  • 9

    Nice but Hard to Wind Up

    I got a full size of this in the brown shade in my Birchbox last month! I really like it, it goes great when I wear all nautral shadows or a brown smokey eye. It is really hard to wind up to get more of the product. A lot of people have said something about this, I thought my stick was broken at first but it just takes a couple of twists. — 2 years, 5 months ago
    ashley_cabell | 16 reviews

    This review is:  Helpful  |  Not helpful  |  Inappropriate  |  0 of 0 people said helpful

  • 16 Best Eyeliners under $10

    Exclusively from the editors at Total Beauty

    Get the Buying Guide to see these top-rated products!

    Get it now »
  • 9

    Stays put

    It stays on till you take it off. I can apply it at 7:00 am and it's still there at 10:00 pm when I go to take off my makeup, even on my lower lids. You do not need to press hard at all. You need a soft hand to apply so that you don't over apply. — 2 years, 6 months ago
    ljcampbell | 5 reviews

    This review is:  Helpful  |  Not helpful  |  Inappropriate  |  1 of 1 people said helpful

  • 7

    love the colors but not a lot of product for the price

    These liners really do stay on until you decide to take them off, and some of the colors really are lovely. But there isn't very much product in there. Sure, I rarely use up an eyeliner, but it's still a bit annoying that there's so little in that pencil. Would buy good colors again, though. — 2 years, 10 months ago
    jkschmier | 38 reviews

    This review is:  Helpful  |  Not helpful  |  Inappropriate  |  0 of 0 people said helpful

  • 7

    pricey but works

    It costs $20 which is a lot for eyeliner. I got it because it doesn't rub off and thought it would be good for use during the summer. It goes on smoothly and sets quickly. The color did not fade - which seems to happen with some eyeliners. I wish it was a little cheaper. — 3 years ago
    wavyredhead | 16 reviews

    This review is:  Helpful  |  Not helpful  |  Inappropriate  |  0 of 0 people said helpful

  • 2

    Not Impressed

    It's too dark, if you don't smudge it and it runs down your face halfway through the day. If you do smudge it, it still runs down your face. Not impressed. — 3 years, 4 months ago
    Pink52087 | 10 reviews

    This review is:  Helpful  |  Not helpful  |  Inappropriate  |  0 of 0 people said helpful

Welcome to!
Ready to unleash your inner beauty junkie? Enter your email and check the boxes below to get free samples, exclusive deals, discounts at Total Beauty Shops, and expert beauty tips delivered straight to your inbox!
Email to a friend