Shiseido The Makeup Lip Liner Pencil by Shiseido, Lip Liner Review

Reviews » Makeup » Lip Liner » Shiseido The Makeup Lip Liner Pencil » Reviews

Add us to your safe send list so our newsletters arrive in your inbox. How do I do this?

13 Best Face Powders

19 Best Blushes

15 Best Lip Liners

7 Makeup Brushes You Actually Need

15 Best Primers for Long-Lasting Eye Makeup

Shiseido The Makeup Lip Liner Pencil 10.0 out of 10 based on 10.0 ratings. 10.0 user reviews.

10

Shiseido The Makeup Lip Liner Pencil
TWMichello (160 reviews)

I have had this lipliner for years and I always go back to it. I haven't found another lipliner yet that is the exact color of my lips. This defines my lips without getting the obvious line and matches just about every lipstick I own. Definately YLBB and I would purchase again but sadly enough it's been discontinued and replaced by a new line op lip pencils. I still have a fair bit so I am still good for now, but I'll be sad once it's gone! Bought it based on the reviews on MUA and because I can`t resist talks about new perfect YLBB NUDE lipliner. So far I like it. Many other so-called nude pencils were frankly yellowish-beige on me. Sometimes that goes on OK, but sometimes it`s annoying cause it is against the true lip colour. This is my experience in nude liners (in comparison with Shiseido one): Clarins Nude - is nice, creamy (more creamy), yellowish - beige (absolutely no tink of pink!) Other "yellowish-beige shades" I have tried in hope to find smthing nude - Revlon Spice, Beyu 522, Body Shop Beach. Rimmel Addiction 018 - very close match (the tone), not yellowish!!!! just a bit lighter than Shiseido and the staying power is worse. Still I like Rimmel because it`s cheap. And don`t like it cause it`s automatic. Mary Kay Neutral - less pinky, more brownish. The same degree of colour intensity. But again - don`t like it`s automatic and the quality is worse. Isa Dora Nude (it`s the name, like Chanel:) - the colour is pinkish-greyish, but on me it turns more greish and of rather unpleasant shade. Chanel Nude - don`t own it, have tried it in a shop. Can`t understand WHO EVER can call this bronze-brown colour "Nude"?? Was it a joke? So, to total it down: Up to the moment Shiseido is really a staple. The only grudge is the price. Which is steep. For the rest - I recommend it and would buy again IF won`t find smthing even more ideal. For those who think it`s still too expensive - Rimmel is a very good option. You can throw away all your other "nude" lipliners. This one works on almost everyone. Especially us ppp girls when all others show up too orange or brown. This one is the perfect pinky light neutral brown. I use it with EVERYTHING including my fave San Fran Cargo lip gloss for a really natural sexy lip. bad thing: I also have trouble with the cap staying on. Seems like it's too big for the pencil. — 1 month, 3 weeks ago

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 0 of 0 people said helpful
10

Love these colors!
thedragonslady (472 reviews)

The colors are great, application a breeze! Long lasting,can also fill lips in like a lipstick. Apply with lip balm or gloss for sheer color. — 4 years, 2 months ago

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 2 of 2 people said helpful
10

Great Color
SubCulture (228 reviews)

I have this in RS303, a vibrant rosy mauve pink. I got this in a gift with purchase and thought it would be too dark or bright but it blends in with my lips without harsh lines. This works great with pink and peachy pink lipsticks and glosses by making the lip colors more vibrant and intense. Also very long lasting and not drying. — 1 year, 2 months ago

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 1 of 1 people said helpful
Buying Guide
15 Best Lip Liners
10

Awesome Lipliner
NT02360 (34 reviews)

I am no fan of Shiseido makeup, but I got hooked on the "wine haze" lipliner years ago. I believe it's been discontinued, but I stocked up on strawberrynet. It is simply the perfect wine lipliner. It has no trace of brown, purple or burgundy. It is a dark blue-based red, which looks fabulous on dark skin and complements all of my lipsticks nicely, especially "cherry jubilee" from Avon. — 2 years, 11 months ago

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 2 of 2 people said helpful
10

The best ever!
GoyaLL (33 reviews)

I will not change this one, it's clear now! After trying cheaper brands like MAC i learned to appreciate the qualities of this liner. Very long lasting, colors are natural, number 2 is the most amazing nude color: you can wear it with any lipstick and it will upgrade it. Survives humidity of 95% and doesn't go into lines. Do yourself a favor and doesn't waist your money, buy this one! — 3 years, 9 months ago

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 1 of 1 people said helpful
10

Truly long-lasting!
momsrtalking (11 reviews)

This is a must-have lipliner, great colors, easy to apply and the consistency is just perfect. Truly worth buying, great for parties, coz the color tends to stay even after eating & drinking, I would blot it all over my lips and just put a lipgloss on top! Great product!!! — 3 years, 9 months ago

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 1 of 1 people said helpful