Editor's Rating & Review
Stila Multi-Effect Mascara promises to do the work of three formulas: volumize, lengthen and curl. Sound too good to be true? It is, but Stila at least gets two jobs done. The thick brush with densely packed bristles helps add volume while the curved shape helps boosts curl a bit. Only length leaves a lot to be desired. A large tube and a deep, inky black help justify the high price and low color selection. So if what you seek is a basic formula that lasts all day without flaking or smudging, this mascara is worth trying.
Stila Multi-Effect Mascara Reviews
Get a different mascara!This product was part of a gift set that was on sale at Sephora. PROS: The color pigmentation was decent (black), the texture was okay. I like the sleek silver packaging. No clumping, flaking or smudging problems. CONS: But, Stila's Multi-Effect Mascara is worse than most d/s mascara. Caused my eyes to become slightly red and irritated (and I've hardly ever had any eye products do that!). I hate the curved brush applicator because there was always too much product stuck to the end of it. Also, I hate curved mascara brushes generally, and prefer a straight brush. I didn't see 'multiple effects'--just regular mascara. Weighs down my lashes a bit, which I've never had problems with before. Difficult to remove, even with makeup remover labeled for waterproof mascara removal. May be contributing to me losing lashes! It was just a not-very-good mascara. Overall, this is not a product I will be buying. I might not even use it all, b/c it's hard to remove and seems to be damaging my lashes a little. — 4 years, 1 month agoLipglossandSpandex | 520 reviews
Volume and DramaThis is a great mascara for creating a dramatic look for your eyes. The mascara brush coats on the formula thick but not clumpy. It adds volume and definition to each lash and lengthens a little. This is great for everyday for a good luck. — 4 years, 7 months agoStef42678 | 484 reviews
New favorite mascaraHoly fabulous eyelashes! All I can say about this mascara is wow. I got this as part of the Sephora mascara sampler kit and I think I found my new favorite mascara. I have non-existent lashes without lots of help. I generally curl my lashes, add a lash building primer, then add a couple coats of mascara. Stila Multi Effect Mascara does all three without clumping. The curved brush lets me get right up to the lash line and the end is tapered enough that I can get to the smallest lashes at the corners of my eyes. So far, I haven't had any flaking, smudging or raccoon eyes by the end of the day. It's pretty easy to remove with regular facial cleanser as well. Even my husband asked me if I was experimenting with false lashes! — 3 years, 2 months agoradar626 | 322 reviews
My Reasons for Reporting This