This isn't a new look for Mary Kate, but I still must ask: Is this the remains of last night's makeup? Defective mascara? Or could it be on purpose? I need to know.

(I can always anonymously send her my fave Lancome Bifacil Double-Action Eye Makeup Remover as a hint...)

• Guilty of this? Make sure don't commit other makeup felonies

• See equally horrifying makeup looks here

• Into pretty makeup? These celebs are worth copying