Home » Beauty Tips » Makeup » Makeup tips » 16 Worst Drugstore Makeup Products

16 Worst Drugstore Makeup Products

See which clumpy mascaras and flytrap sticky lip glosses our readers urge you to stay away from

2 of 17

No. 16: Maybelline New York Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Mascara, $6.94

TotalBeauty.com average reader rating: 5.9*
Why: Readers say, "I know hate is a strong word but ... I hate this mascara! The brush was too thin, the mascara smelled bad and it didn't do anything for my lashes except give it clumps." Another reader who is Asian with short, straight eyelashes says, "this mascara did not work for me. When I applied Maybelline's Stiletto mascara, the curl that I got from the Shu Uemura eyelash curler was gone!" One reader was disappointed saying, "the mascara is nothing like the commercial says it is." Another says, "I found the consistency just awful, which I should have taken as an omen that the product would not wear well, which it did not. The mascara wore off about half-way through my day [and] the raccoon circles under my eyes were definitely not the effect I was looking for."

Agree? Disagree? Write your review here.

*At time of publication

See Next Page: No. 15: Milani Loose Makeup, $7.99

Rate this story|Avg member rating: 8

Maybelline New York Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Washable Mascara

Average Member Rating: 5.8

Milani Loose Makeup

Average Member Rating: 5.7

CoverGirl TRUblend Microminerals Foundation

Average Member Rating: 4.9

Revlon Sugar Sugar Lip Topping

Average Member Rating: 5.2

Sally Hansen Line Smoothing Airbrush Primer

Average Member Rating: 5.4

Neutrogena Healthy Skin Glow Sheers

Average Member Rating: 5.6

Sally Hansen Lip Inflation Plumping Treatment

Average Member Rating: 5.3

Rimmel London Recover Concealer

Average Member Rating: 4.9

N.Y.C. New York Color Liquid Lip Shine Lipgloss

Average Member Rating: 4.5

Wet n Wild MegaPlump Mascara

Average Member Rating: 4.2

L'Oréal Paris Micro Liner Ultra Fine Lining Pencil

Average Member Rating: 4.6

CoverGirl Outlast Double LipShine

Average Member Rating: 3.3

Revlon 3D Extreme Waterproof Mascara

Average Member Rating: 3.3

Rimmel London Colour Rush Duo Eyeshadow

Average Member Rating: 2.9

Wet n Wild IdolEyes Retractable Eye Pencil

Average Member Rating: 3.5

Physicians Formula Retro Glow Ultra-Dramatic Mascara for a false eyelash effect

Average Member Rating: 2.5

11 Best Makeup Looks for Summer

Find out which of these celebrity makeup looks will work best on your skin tone

Get Luxe Hair and Makeup Looks for Less

We dared ourselves to recreate celebrity hairstyles and makeup looks that normally cost hundreds of dollars using only drugstore beauty products. Did we succeed?

What's the Best Lip Color for You?

Find out which shade will perfectly complement your skin tone -- then make it your go-to hue

I totally agree about the Lash Stiletto mascara; I wanted to love it SO much but I hated it!

by Karica4 Wednesday, May 23, 2012 at 12:30PM Report as inappropriate

Hate Maybelline mascaras. This is the only brand that straightens my lashes, even when I curl them!!!

by darkangel81 Wednesday, May 9, 2012 at 04:42PM Report as inappropriate

thanks

by Benahir Thursday, April 26, 2012 at 05:16PM Report as inappropriate

Hated the Cover girl items mentioned!

by jola64 Friday, April 20, 2012 at 01:18PM Report as inappropriate

I agree with the comment about the Stilleto brand, I absolutely hate the eyeliner too.... terrible applicator, terrible consistency.... runs everywhere. Just hate the whole line.

by marithinks Tuesday, April 17, 2012 at 10:23PM Report as inappropriate