Christina AguileraChristina ignored one of the first rules of makeup -- which is to only play up one feature at a time. Instead she had dramatic eyes, lips and cheeks, far left, which was just too much. In the other photo, she sported toned-down eyes and cheeks, making her red lips the focus -- much better.
What do you think? Talk about her looks on our message boards.
Images: Getty Images, taken in New York City on March 23, 2007, and in Los Angeles on September 16, 2007
SEE NEXT PAGE: Tyra Banks