15 Best Liners
From MAC and Smashbox to Wet n Wild, the pencils that got top ratings and product reviews
Why it's great: "This highly pigmented, chubby crayon delivers long-lasting wear with some moisture. The rich matte finish works remarkably well in the strong reds, though any of the colors can be topped with gloss. (Just know this affects length of wear.) Vitamin E and silicone help you forget you're wearing rich color. A pencil makes for pretty precise application -- but eventually you'll be reaching for a Nars custom-sized sharpener (which you must buy separately -- boo)." -- Beth, Editor-in-Chief
Agree? Disagree? Write your review here.
SEE NEXT PAGE: DuWop Reverse Lip Liner, $19