Editors' Pick: 11 Best Mascaras
See which eye makeup products gave our editors lust-worthy lashes
What she thought: "This mascara has gotten me more compliments than any other makeup product I've tried. From multiple friends' 'wow, what mascara are you using?' to my boss' 'um, this is a weird thing to say, but your eyelashes look amazing,' I've never gotten this big of a reaction from so little effort.
To sum it up, this mascara adds major length and a fair amount of volume too. It definitely creates a dramatic (as opposed to natural) look. However, it does take some finessing. The product can be a bit liquid-y and will clump lashes together if you don't take your time with it. But if you make use of the brush's two sides -- a standard brush on half and a comb on the other -- and comb through your lashes after applying, you'll get rid of any clumps and be left with almost-fake-looking eyelashes."