What she thought: "With mascara prices on the rise, this one won't break the bank. At only $3, you get great, natural-looking lashes. While it sells itself as making lashes look up to 80 percent longer, I'd say mine came in at only 40 percent improved. However, the formula didn't clump and it provided a subtle curl that brightened up my eyes. After applying only two coats, I noticed a marked improvement in my lashes. Be sure you remove with makeup remover, because simple soap and water won't make this formula budge, which I like."
SEE NEXT PAGE: MAC Plush Lash Mascara, $14