Why it's great: The eye shadow championship goes to these affordable matte duos. With rich color pairings, smooth application and staying power, this product excels on all fronts. "They are true to color, last all day and night, and are easy to blend," one user dishes. "They provide many color options, a great price, and intense pigment. You cannot go wrong!" The shadow's sky-high quality speaks for itself; according to our readers, "you won't believe" it's a drug-store product.
Agree? Disagree? Write your review here.
*At time of publication
SEE NEXT PAGE: No. 1: Jane Iredale PurePressed Eye Shadows, $28