No. 12: Almay Blendable Eye Pencil, $7.39TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 9.2*
Why it's great: "This goes on smooth and doesn't smudge (unless you want it to!). I wear eyeliner everyday and this is one of my favorites. [And it] compares to high-end brands," says one reader while another simply states "AWESOME. Can't beat it for the $."
Agree? Disagree? Write your review here.
*At time of publication
SEE NEXT PAGE: No. 11: St. Ives Whipped Silk Intense Body Moisturizer, $4.99