No. 1: MAC Mattene Lipstick $12.50TotalBeauty.com average reader rating: 9.6*
Why: Readers say, "the colors are beautiful, the pigment rich and intense and the finish is silky and matte" and even though "it's definitely a matte finish, it glides on smoothly and doesn't look dried out or dry out your lips." One reader thinks that "Mattenes are so great, everyone has to have at least one. There are quite a few flattering colors and they last all day." A reader touts that "it does everything it claims! It goes on light as air and stays on." Another reader asserts, "this is one of the best lipsticks ever."
*At time of publication