Home»Message Boards»Obsess About Makeup Here» Most Overrated Brand/Products?

«Back to the topics

Most Overrated Brand/Products?

Author

Message

MissMOI

5 posts

Community member since 05/11/2008

CAbeautyjunkie wrote:

I think Bare Escentuals is OVERRATTED! I have been using it for almost a year and just recently decided to stop. My skin has never looked worse and is breaking out like crazy. Nothing else in my beauty regimen has changed, so I know my issue are linked to Bare Escentuals. I know it's "all natural" and they claim it's good for your skin, but I disagree. Does anyone have any recommendations for "gentle" (I have sensitive skin) make up that they have been happy with?


I have an e-boutique, www.moiskincare.com. Email me, elizabeth@moiskincare.com with your skin type and specifics about your sensitivities and I would be more than glad to send you some free samples! :-)

btyadt

45 posts

Community member since 04/05/2008

KFoxalicious wrote:

I think Bare Escentuals and Proactiv are way overrated.


I totally agree! I tried Proactiv because i had HORRIBLE acne, it did help me, but it smelled SO bad and left my skin kind of red, and then I seemed to build a tolerance to it! Plus, proactiv is so inconvenient to get a hold of. It is overrated.

And I'm using Maybelline Great Lash right now...not impressed with it at all.

Kiss_and_Makeup

2 posts

Community member since 06/03/2008

I politely disagree...I find that their bronzers are wonderful..as are their blush...the consistency of their products is great...not at all chalky like many of their competitors. Although they're pricey I do believe their products are a better buy than just about any because of their quality.

Kiss_and_Makeup

2 posts

Community member since 06/03/2008

this was meant for the Benefit makeup...somehow it ended up here *confused look*

GasolineGirl

23 posts

Community member since 05/02/2008

CAbeautyjunkie wrote:

I think Bare Escentuals is OVERRATTED! I have been using it for almost a year and just recently decided to stop. My skin has never looked worse and is breaking out like crazy. Nothing else in my beauty regimen has changed, so I know my issue are linked to Bare Escentuals. I know it's "all natural" and they claim it's good for your skin, but I disagree. Does anyone have any recommendations for "gentle" (I have sensitive skin) make up that they have been happy with?



I guess that I would have to disagree, I LOVE Bare Escentuals, everything that they make is awesome, I'm so obsessed with it, that I think I'm gonna have to find a 12 step program. LOL But, I guess that everyone is diffrent, what works for one person doesn't work for another. One makeup that I feel is overrated is BeautiControl, it makes me break out something awful.

BonJour773

10 posts

Community member since 06/09/2008

canuckinla wrote:

I agree with all of the posts! La Mer-got a sample a few yrs ago and would LOVE a whole jar of moisturizer. It's less expensive than I thought but I'd probably get obsessed and have to buy all their stuff.LOL! I also agree that Benefit can be overrated, I love their stuff for a few months and then get sick of it. I also found their packaging slightly annoying and impractical. As for Stila, I am loyal to their eye shadows and their illuminating concealer. I kind of like their lip glaze but I find that Stila is very pricey. I do however, love the texture and saturation of the eye shadow.


I hear you ...I got a sample about two years ago and now that is all I use...I have become obsessed...however, I do feel it does a great job for me and I see results...so I know...its a great product!!!

cybelesays

7 posts

Community member since 10/17/2007

Great Lash is overrated! I don't get it. Could it just not work on me? nonsense! I just thought is gave me stubby lashes and at the end of the day (this was a long time ago), I couldn't get it off. not fun.

btyadt

45 posts

Community member since 04/05/2008


CAbeautyjunkie wrote:



One makeup that I feel is overrated is BeautiControl, it makes me break out something awful.


I absolutely hate beauticontrol. ugh. That stuff was so rough on my skin...ugh I just can't stand to talk about it!

Miss_Vicki

20 posts

Community member since 07/09/2008

Bianca_S wrote:


As far as overrated products...definitely Maybelline Great Lash Mascara. How does it always get voted as the best mascara in Allure?


I'm with you there. Every Maybelline mascara I've ever tried gave me a major case of raccoon eyes. I never understood the fuss over Great Lash.

Also, I've never cared for Clinique products. I do like Estee Lauder but only get them from my grandma when she gets the "free with purchase" lipsticks and mascara (I have two tubes of Rosa Rosa lipstick because of that) since my budget is too tight for me to buy them. I mostly buy Cover Girl.

littlelambbb

15 posts

Community member since 06/27/2008

I agree with the Maybelline Great Lash comments. Soooo overrated! I don't understand it, it did nothing special to my eyelashes. Just made them clumpy and stubby looking. Also, agree with the Bare Escentuals comments. Basically I think all of the mineral makeup products are overrated. I've tried them. I see nothing special about them at all. Benefit products are ok, but overpriced. Really like Benetint though. I think the original is always the best and there are a lot of lip/cheek stains out there now, but Benetint is the original and still the best cheek stain out there to me. Just expensive. Stila is really overrated to me too. Tried a bunch of their eyeshadows about a year ago and was completely underwhelmed. Lastely, anything and everything by Clarins to me is way overrated. The products do not do ANYTHING they claim to. Especially the new Young Longer Balm. $98.00 worth of crap!

Showing 41-50 of 65 posts

 

Welcome to Total Beauty!

As a member you can review products, get personalized recommendations, watch how-to videos and more!

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Total Beauty Footer boot