Advertisements

Welcome!

Sign in to review beauty products and for info on our free samples program.

Close
Home»Message Boards»Obsess About Makeup Here» Most Overrated Brand/Products?

«Back to the topics

Most Overrated Brand/Products?

Author

Message

Bianca_S

190 posts

Community member since 10/15/2007

Oh yeah, they've definitely got a VERY clever marketing strategy going on there. Their marketing executive must be rolling in it!

CurlyBelle

23 posts

Community member since 03/11/2008

I agree with everyone about Benefit. I'm such a pushover for great packaging that I buy their products a lot and then feel let down! Especially the Boo Boo Zap - totally useless. I think La Mer is way too hyped too. I've tried the eye balm and didn't love it. Kiehl's is better.

chitownchik

32 posts

Community member since 11/25/2007

Lifeofaladybug wrote:

I totally agree about benefit. I also think, other than the foundation (which I love), bareEscentuals is way overrated. As are Smashbox and LORAC.


I totally agree with you about bareEscentuals. I bought their starter kit from sephora and am dying to get rid of it by now. it's such a hassle. the only product i like is the mineral veil.

nillacookie

141 posts

Community member since 10/17/2007

I have yet to try Kiehl's, but I'm hoping to soon. I've heard so much about how great they are. I hope it lives up to my expectations.

What are your favorite products?

BeautyChick101

108 posts

Community member since 12/03/2007

nillacookie wrote:

I have yet to try Kiehl's, but I'm hoping to soon. I've heard so much about how great they are. I hope it lives up to my expectations.

What are your favorite products?

Kiehl's is pretty amazing I think! Their Abyssine+ eye cream has definitely gotten my dark circles down to a minimum.

I am not a fan of La Mer as much as I should be, I guess! I like their eye cream but most of their products are too rich and heavy for my skin and actually tend to make it feel tight and break out!

makeupjunkie13

66 posts

Community member since 02/11/2008

I was really sad to discover that I HATE Philosophy's Hope in a Jar! It did nothing for my parched skin and has a stinky smell like sweaty socks! I got the 2 oz jar which is way over priced and because I had to slap on so much it disappeared quickly! I'm glad it's done now - I gave it a fair run 2 months.

Agree about some of Benefit's products. Love the packaging but so not convenient or functional. I am a fan of Hoola, Lip Plump (not for the plumping effect but it's an awesome primer) and Dandelion (for my fair skinned clients), but hate that most of their products only suit fair-med skin tones. Glosses textures are great but too sheer for me. I'm sorry but the eye brightner does not work! It looks so chalky on my skin.

Love Stila shadows and tinted moisturizer but they are a little pricey. Stila Lip Glaze lovers don't hate me but I hate their glosses. Not sticky but I find they're too sheer and run out so quickly. sorry!

Maybelline Great Lash is over hyped and is great for someone that wants natural lashes but it smudges and runs like crazy! Ugh! Hated it!

BlackberryAddict

65 posts

Community member since 12/10/2007

Jen_FiftyCentHead wrote:

Please don't shoot me, but Stila is overrated! I don't find most of the products to be terribly inspired...


ABSOLUTELY! I do like the convertable color though - but everything else is horribly overrated. I really don't like their eye shadows at all. I never look at Stila. Never. The only reason I bought the convertable color was because I wanted a cream blush when my skin was very dry - and they included a GWP. The GWP was lipgloss which I don't like either.

I also think I could live without MAC - I know - someone must be ready to kill me. II only like a few things from MAC.

KFoxalicious

15 posts

Community member since 02/14/2008

I think Bare Escentuals and Proactiv are way overrated.

canuckinla

312 posts

Community member since 01/11/2008

(I started this topic)

I agree with Bare Escentuals being overrated. I swore I'd never buy the stuff but I was swatching and infomercial and I got sucked in. Then a friend told me about it and I rushed out to get a starter kit. Stopped using it within a day and tried to pawn it off on another friend who said, no thanks; she was trying to pawn hers off as well!

kgraulty

152 posts

Community member since 02/15/2008

KFoxalicious wrote:

I think Bare Escentuals and Proactiv are way overrated.


Bare Escentuals was the one of the worst powder foundations I have ever tried. It made me greasy halfway through the day and didn't cover well. My sister swears by it though.

Showing 11-20 of 74 posts

 

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT