Maybelline New York One by One by Volum' Express Washable Mascara

Stuck too long

My first tube of this product was fantastic. I thought I was going to be a die-hard brand fan. But, my second tube was very thick. The mascara stuck to my lashes, and even after multiple washes and attempts with makeup remover, I still had residual mascara clumps. Did anyone else have this problem?

September 26, 2011